Canada Flag

Canadian Stamp Auctions

Stamp Market Commentary

Commentary No. 125 - 17 November, 2009

The S. J. Menich Collection of Canada’s Large Queens
Sold by Charles G. Firby
February 6, 1997


This impressive collection of Large Queens had everything. It included essays, die proofs, imprint blocks, strips, a great number of paper, colour and perforation varieties, together with Bothwell, Stitch and Pirie watermarks.

Perhaps the most outstanding feature was the large number of beautiful Large Queen blocks, greater than we can ever recall seeing.

There is no way we can do justice to the amount of knowledge Menich must have had to identify and collect the various colours, papers and perforations that separate one variety from another. But fortunately for collectors, many of the rules he learned over time were summarized in the auction catalogue, to be shared with collectors at large.

What follows is a very brief overview of this extraordinary collection.

(Prices realized have been converted at the rate of $1US = $1.35 Cdn.)

21b
Black
Lot 841
Watermarked paper,
Showpiece
Realized $5,738

21
Black, Full counter & imprint
Lot 829
LH & NH, including the “Spur flaw”
Realized $4,050

22a
Red Brown, Bothwell watermark
Lot 872
Showpiece, trivial crease
Realized $1,755

22
Brown Red
Strong Vertical Stitch Watermark
Lot 860
Very rare, Showpiece,
Ex Lussey, Richardson
Realized $1,013

22
Red Brown
Lot 861
Showpiece, Full OG
Realized $4,050

23
Orange, The Absolute GEM of the Menich Collection
Lot 883
XF, full OG, Largest recorded multiple,
Ex Lee-Jones, Smart, Jarrett, Firth,
Leggett & Lindsey
Realized $40,500

24a
Blue Green

Lot 949
Showpiece with Bothwell Watermark
Realized $1,4

24iv
Blue Green
Lot 950
Stunning Showpiece, full OG, on Bothwell paper
Realized $3,038

25
Red
Lot 989
World class rarity & showpiece, Full OG, Ex- Dale – Lichtenstein
Realized $16,200

26ii
Olive Green
Lot 1036
XF, Rare 12 x 12 perf.
Realized $1,890

26
Olive Green
Lot 1034
VF+, Full streaky brownish OG,
bottom 2 stamps NH,
Ex-Dale Lichtenstein
Realized $11,475

27iv
Yellow Brown
Lot 1048
Partial double print on piece, the most dramatic of the 4 existing
Realized $24,300

27
Brown
Lot 1056
Block of 6, Full OG, an impressive showpiece
Realized $13,500

28
Pale Dull Blue
Lot 1103
OG, Ex- Jarrett & Firth
Realized $5,063

28
Pale Dull Blue
Lot 1102
Full OG NH
Realized $11,475

28i
Pale Blue
Lot 1141
XF, showpiece, 3rd largest unused multiple of this stamp, some thinning
Realized $6,750

28
Dull Blue
Lot 1129
XF, strong “horizontal stitch watermark”
(Unlisted until the 2009 Unitrade Catalogue)
Realized $810

29d,ii
Dark Brown Purple
Lot 1217
XF imperforate corner block, NH with Pawnbroker variety UR, psn. 10
Realized $8,775

29i
Slate Purple
Lot 1209
Showpiece, NH OG, light crease in margin
Realized $2,430

30d
Dull Grey
Lot 1233
F-VF. showpiece, the rare script watermark
Realized $2,565

30ii
Deep Blue
Lot 1271
VF NH showpiece
Realized $5,400

As we look back over this collection of extraordinary blocks and varieties, we can only shake our head in amazement at what Mr. Menich managed to collect. It was such an outstanding collection.

Once again, our sincere thanks to Mr. John Cooper for not only lending us this auction catalogue from his collection, but also for giving us the opportunity to see a collection of this caliber. We are glad to be able to share it with you.

Thanks also to Charles G. Firby Auctions, which responded promptly to our request for a copy of the prices realized for this auction.

Canada Map Logo
Return to First Page

Site Meter ©2009, Canadian Stamp Auctions Ltd., Montréal, Québec, Canada